For a quarterback who has yet to start a game in college, Bryce Underwood already has plenty of accolades to his name. He was the No. 1 overall prospect in the 2025 recruiting class and parlayed that success into already appearing on a video-game cover. Given his potential and star power, Underwood seems destined to open the season as Michigan’s starting quarterback, right?

Not so fast.

Michigan head coach Sherrone Moore refused to name Underwood as the team’s starter, calling the position an “open competition” for now. 

That may come as a surprise to some considering Underwood’s status as a highly-touted recruit. But Moore is willing to see what Mikey Keene can do during camp before making his decision. Keene, who joined Michigan as a transfer from Fresno State, threw 18 touchdowns against 11 interceptions last season. While Underwood comes with more hype, Keene does have experience, playing in 39 games over his college career.

For all the excitement over Underwood, he could lack the polish necessary to start from Day 1. Underwood will almost certainly see time as Michigan’s starter this season, but it’s possible Keene’s experience makes him the better option for the team initially. 

Competent quarterback play would go a long way for the Wolverines, who finished 8-5 last season despite a miserable offense. Any improvement on that side of the ball — particularly at quarterback — would go a long way toward making Michigan a national-championship contender. Despite last year’s struggles, the team still appears on early top-25 lists ahead of the 2025-26 season.

Moore has a few weeks before he needs to make a decision. Michigan opens the year against New Mexico on Aug. 30. Who will open the season under center when the Wolverines take the field for that contest? Moore is willing to give it some time before he makes that call.